Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Ayurveda Practice and Research
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/71ddf/71ddf13ddad046cf9ae57ed9af79ade9e58b4edf" alt="Image"
Impact is the remarkable influences on the existing system by
forced invade of a new think as like-pandemic disease. This impact
can be interpreted as positive, negative or neutral based on the sensible
variables. It is an essential exercise to assess impact of serious illness
in pandemic form for its negative and positive influence on the
economy, society, public policy, preventive, promotive and curative
health, quality of life, environment and to allocate research project
for maximum benefit with minimum waste of funds and manpower
[1]. Health Impact Assessment (HIA) is a combination of procedures,
methods, and tools used to evaluate the potential health effects of a
policy, programmer or project. Using qualitative, quantitative and
participatory techniques, HIA aims to produce recommendations
that will help decision-makers and other stakeholders make choices
about alternatives and improvements to prevent disease/injury and
to actively promote health [2]. Covid-19 pandemic has a significant
remark in many areas which are reflected in Wikipedia. But its impact
on Ayurveda practice and research is not found either in Wikipedia or
another search engine in internet platform. Therefore, an attempt was
taken to assess the impact of Covid-19 pandemic in Ayurveda practice
& Research.
Ayurveda is a live traditional system of health care with an
unbreakable practice for 3000 years. Ayurveda gained importance
in its own country where it was originated after the establishment of
Department of AYUSH in 2003. Then National Rural Health Mission
(NRHM) includes Ayurveda (one of the components of AYUSH)
as alternative therapy option to integrate with western medicine to
serve the people of India in better way in 2005. Ayurveda health care
is more focussed after the establishment of AYUSH ministry in 2014
[3]. Central council of Research in Ayurveda Sciences (CCRAS) has
also intensified the specific research-based programme and project
and renamed its institute as specific system based to create more
data on practice of Ayurveda & initiate research in 2016. Herbal
medicine is used by 75%-80% of the world population, mainly in
developing countries for primary health care [2]. But only 6.9% of
Indian population favoured AYUSH system of medicine as evident
in NSSO survey in 2014 [4]. Many committees recommended that
more awareness and research are required to popularize the system.
Many patients prefer Ayurveda after dissatisfied or frustration with
contemporary medicine, low cost of Ayurveda medicine in comparison
to allopath, easy excess to Ayurveda physician, last option and less side
effect [5]. More over some patient choose Ayurveda primarily based
on their personal experience and strong recommendation of other
people [6,7]. The Ayurveda diagnostic process is subjective and patient
oriented, some of diagnostic tools such as Prakruti (Constitution)
assessment and Nadi Parikshya (Pulse diagnosis) are also patient
centric. The treatment always personalized and classified as Sodhana
(Purificatory) and Samana (Palliative). The Sodhana therapy is also
called as Panchakarma therapy or detox therapy where snehana
(oleation) and swedana (Sweating) are preparatory therapy which
need personal contact of panchakarma technician and Ayurveda
physician. Ksharasutra, leech therapy and uttara vasti are para surgical
procedures mostly practice in Ayurveda hospitals. The researches in
Ayurveda are academic research in post graduate centers and special
research in Research centers. Some of the academia and Institutes
have been conducting clinical trial, animal experiments and other
researches like Clinical epidemiology, Pharmaco epidemiology etc.,
[8,9].
If health care sector is considered, then various clinical guidelines
are issued for management of COVID-19 patients as well as normal
patients. Research Councils under the Ministry of AYUSH, Government
of India have also issued advisory based on the Indian traditional
medicine practices i.e., Ayurveda, Homeopathy and Unani before the
outbreak in India. A consensus statement in Ayurveda management and
prevention was developed for COVID-19.
Impact on Ayurveda Practice: In the first and 2nd phase of lock
down, many Ayurveda hospital discharged their IPD patients. The
Panchakarma hospitals and message centers completely closed down
which was depend on tourism. All para-surgical procedures and invasive
panchakarma procedure are stopped due to outbreak of COVID-19. In
this stage more asymptomatic cases and carriers are found, which would
amplify the chances of infection, therefore Ayurveda doctors managed
the research and general cases by wearing surgical musk, hand wash by
sanitizers. After that PPE kit was provided to some doctors those are
doing COVID duty. Ayurveda doctors postponed the wellness therapy
and non-urgent cases. IPD services of most of Ayurveda hospital is
closed down. In the Unlock process, some of the Ayurveda hospital and
Medical colleges converted to COVID hospital by its State government.
Some of AYUSH doctors sacrificed their life also.
The impact on Ayurveda Research is also noted in many centers, the
trial subject cannot continue the clinical trials. There is a mass drop out/
partial drop out of subjects from ongoing clinical trials and new patients’
recruitment is not possible for close down of clinical laboratories.
In the midst of the Pandemic, MoHW, in collaboration with Niti
Aayog, released Telemedicine Practice Guidelines enabling Registered
Medical Practitioners to provide healthcare in remote settings using
telemedicine. These guidelines recognized by some of the Ayurveda
hospitals. The patient’s attendance dropped upto 80% of most of Ayurveda
hospitals. The clinical trials cases dropped out the trial due to lock
down process. Whereas new trials on COVID-19 was encouraged and
more positive impacts were generated when Prime Minister Narendra
Modi endorsed traditional ways to boost the immune system, directing
people to follow the guidelines issued by the Ayush ministry to avoid
contracting Covid-19. The prime minister also asked those practicing
traditional medicines to utilise the platform of tele-medicine and reach
out to the people to generate awareness in the fight against the Covid-19
pandemic. Phyto therapeutic agents containing higher concentration
of sesquiterpene, polyphenols and flavonoids have inhibited the
production of inflammatory cytokines and prostaglandin which are
more produced in COVID-19. Yastimadhu, Gilay and Aswagandha have
equal effect on cough as codeine. The Anu taila nasya has special power
to prevent COVID-19. More than 70% of Indian population has been
using Ayurveda Kadha (Decoction), Haldi milk and practice Yogasana
and pranayama for prevention of Covid-19.
Clinical research studies on Ayurveda interventions as prophylaxis
and as an add-on to standard care to Covid-19. A Collaborative clinical
study was proposed as a joint initiative of Ministry of AYUSH, Ministry
of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW) and the Ministry of Science &
Technology through Council of Scientific & Industrial Research (CSIR)
with technical support of ICMR. The Interdisciplinary Ayush R&D
Task Force has formulated and designed clinical research protocols for
prophylactic studies and add-on interventions in COVID-19 positive
cases through a thorough review and consultative process of experts
of high repute from different organisations across the country for
studying four different interventions viz. Ashwagandha, Yashtimadhu,
Guduchi+Pippali and a polyherbal formulation (AYUSH-64) developed
by CCRAS.
Ayush Sanjivani application-based study for impact assessment of
acceptance and usage of AYUSH advisories in its role in the prevention
of Covid-19 is initiated in all Ayurveda Institutes and hospitals. The
Ministry of AYUSH has developed Ayush sanjeevani mobile app, for
generating data of large population with a target of 5 million people.
The Researchers are worked hard to reach to expected outcomes include
to generate data on acceptance and usage of AYUSH advocacies and
measures among the population and its impact on the prevention of
COVID-19.
Although negative impacts are more noted in terms of lock down
of Ayurveda hospitals and Ksharasutra and panchakarma centers.
There is a significant drop of OPD strength due to lock down and
shut down process. But positive impact is more as it creates awareness
to opt Ayurveda kwatha, nasya, pranayama and yagasana to prevent
COVID-19. It also reached every house of India.
Submit manuscript at https://www.scholarscentral.org/submissions/traditional-medicine-clinical-naturopathy.html or send as an e-mail attachment to the Editorial Office at jtmcn@emedscholar.com